Different measures of motion
Teaching Guidance for 14-16
Force and energy
Wrong Track: That bus had lots of force: it had lots of energy before it hit the pillar.
Wrong Track: Kinetic energy and momentum must be the same: both get bigger as you go faster.
Right Lines: There are two useful measures of the
quantity of motion of an object. Neither of these is the force. These measures are the energy in the kinetic store and the momentum.
Distinguishing between force, energy and momentum
Thinking about the learning
This challenge arises from an imprecise use of specialist terms, and perhaps from too much reliance on language alone. There are quantities that are reduced when an object is brought to rest, but none of these is the
force, as a moving object does not have
Momentum and energy are both reduced when the object is brought to rest. The motion will stop when the energy in the kinetic store is shifted elsewhere – for example, once the brakes have been applied (a thermal store is filled as the brakes and surrounding air are warmed). A free-wheeling vehicle will eventually stop once the frictional forces have shifted all the energy from the kinetic store. In describing such behaviour as
running out of force, we can see pupils with almost the right idea but mixing the terms
Thinking about the teaching
Elsewhere we've suggested ways of introducing forces that we think will help students identify them accurately (in the SPT: Forces topic). The key point is that they are a way of describing the interactions of the object with the environment. Both momentum and the energy in the kinetic store are properly attributes of the object (at least from a particular point of view), and so could increase or decrease as the object's motion changes. Of course, one is a scalar and one a vector – a distinction probably best made by drawing.
There are fundamental differences between momentum and energy, but we'd suggest that it's far more profitable to focus on seeing how the ideas are used, as it's this experience-based skill that will bring students a good feel for the ideas.