Circular Motion
Forces and Motion

Centrifugal motion at a fun fair

Teaching Guidance for 14-16 PRACTICAL PHYISCS

Consider using this thought experiment about a common example of circular motion to stimulate a fruitful classroom discussion.

Suppose that two boys, A and B, visit one of those amusements at a fair in which people sit on a floor that rotates. A and B enter the room while the floor is at rest, and sit on the polished floor. Knowing the trick of the performance, A glues himself to the floor. When the floor begins to spin A notes that a mysterious force seems to pull him outward. But for the glue, it would make him slide out to the wall.

B, without glue; slides out to the wall if A does not hold on to him, exerting an inward pull on him. Each boy feels he is struggling against centrifugal force.

But now let a stationary observer take a bird's eye view from above. Seen from outside the spinning room, A and B are each moving in a circular orbit; and each needs a real inward force to keep him in orbit. For B, the force is the inward pull which A provides: for A it is the pull of the sticky floor on him. The boy A merely imagines an outward force on B because he has to apply a real inward force to him. As the outsider sees, these inward forces are not neutralizing a mysterious outward force; they are making an inward acceleration; they are making A and B move in a curve.

The outside observer offers a further comment. He sees that when A lets go; B continues along a tangent (if there is no friction). B's successive positions along that tangent are farther and farther out from the centre of the circle; so, as seen by A (revolving with the floor), B seems to be sliding out along a radius. But really B is just continuing a straight (tangent) path, a simple example of Newton's first law.

Centrifugal force is a delusion due to living in the rotating system and trying to forget it.

The rotating-floor discussion leads straight to this view. To people sitting on the floor in a concealing fog – and ignoring its motion – there is an outward field of force, endowing every mass m with an outward force mv 2R.

Unless some real agent applies an inward force to balance this, any object left alone will seem to slide outward with acceleration v 2R. A sober view from outside says that both the outward field of force and the outward sliding are delusions due to living in a rotating framework and not allowing for its motion.

Circular Motion
can be analysed using the quantity Centripetal Acceleration
can be described by the relation F=m(v^2)/R
Limit Less Campaign

Support our manifesto for change

The IOP wants to support young people to fulfil their potential by doing physics. Please sign the manifesto today so that we can show our politicians there is widespread support for improving equity and inclusion across the education sector.

Sign today